2024-05-30 02:44:24
“my” vs. “mine” in the numerous manager possessive : a-laser.com


“my” vs. “mine” in the numerous manager possessive

August 29, 2022

“I so delight in your bringing my personal and you will Gregg’s boy to college today.” – however, I would suggest “our very own kid” or perhaps the kid’s term might possibly be more natural than “my and you can Gregg’s guy”?

Once i go along with Warsaw Usually, would it remain grammatically proper to use “mine” in this instance, if you believe from “mine” given that writing about “my son”? That’s, what if the growlr first phrase are this?:

- Ok, but I do believe Gregg’s man will happen first in one to instance to make obvious what “mine” was dealing with:

Indeed, it is really not very clear throughout the modern whether we have been speaking regarding a couple of pupils. In case it is that, plus the audio speaker still wants to speak about both themself and you will Gregg, then i imagine “Gregg’s and you can my boy” might possibly be more natural than just “My personal and Gregg’s child”. Of course, if there’s two – I’d favor “Gregg’s and you may my family”, I believe.

Hey porsche, I’m still not sure

- I know it is not that which you expected, but the way more I believe about this, the newest reduced cause I find to mention often Gregg otherwise me personally; the other person knows whoever kid are inside. When we establish the daughter so you’re able to individuals I really don’t imagine i constantly state, “This might be Gregg’s and you can my personal girl”, however, both “It is all of our child” otherwise “It is my child”. Secondly, I think we’d be more browsing state “my personal boy” otherwise “my personal girl” than just “my personal son”, would not we? Or once i said before, merely have fun with their title:

To the analogy provided about new question, my personal is correct and you will mine grammatically impossible – the rest is concept.

- We agree totally that everything you state is the treatment for the fresh unique question, although others is not just on the style, it is more about category of pure. I simply don’t believe you to definitely “my personal and Gregg’s man” are absolute English. It does not sound for me eg something a native speaker carry out state.

Will, I trust most you told you, except for anything

You asserted that the first sentence is not very obvious. I disagree. All the version help with thus far provides an extremely particular definition:

are only able to imply the exact same thing. A number of will say this is ungrammatical, having “my” coming very first, in case not ungrammatical, it is no less than believed rude because of the every. This pronoun move is very improper, despite casual message. For folks who talk along these lines, men, “educated” or otherwise not, have a tendency to imagine you might be a young teenager whom can not lay out its portable.

can also only indicate Greg keeps a kid, you may have a different sort of kid, and you will some body got one another college students to college. While this and additionally matical, it is still impolite. Comprehend the review above on the “my”.

Mention, evey single one of those systems is entirely unambiguous. Perhaps are common grammatical, however some are to be eliminated having grounds mentioned.

History, Tend to, their remark in regards to the need to talk about Greg is extremely well pulled. Especially for cases where Greg along with a kid with her, it will be unlikely to refer Greg whatsoever (rendering it even clearer one to “mine” meaans a couple various other children). Earliest, of the bringing up Greg, it’s at the very least suggested that he’s not actually establish. If it is actually the outcome, why should the guy even be mentioned? You would merely state

I totally concur that most of the sentences you’ve provided is unambiguous, but these are typically all outcome of all of our interpretation of new sentence. Ok, due to the fact sbee up coming requires if this is going to be ‘my’, he does inform you, however, if i take the completely new sentence since it really stands without one to comment, i quickly still think it is unsure. I thinkl that is what I suggested.

Be Sociable, Share!
  • Connect with Us:

    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn RSS Feeds